"Why don't you ever learn to keep your big mouth shut."
— Annie Lennox, "Why"
I've blogged about Facebook a number of times. If you want to read what I've written about this before, you can click on the Facebook topic in my archives, on the right side of the screen and read those posts.
To recap, I can say that I resisted FB for years, until realized that I was missing lots of family and friend news and photos, joined for that reason, then discovered that it was an important tool for book marketing, and finally embraced it. I was warned by Serena, my "social media guru," that I should stay on point — not get pulled into discussions about anything other than my book — and I adhered to that on my FB fan page.
As for my personal FB page, I knee-jerked into responding to other's political, religious, and whatever posts, then started posting my own opinions. Especially during the election. How does anyone resist? Not necessarily to change anyone's mind, but to be heard?
Water under the bridge now...
So, my FB friends who are paying attention know what I think on a number of issues. I know what they think. There is agreement among some, acceptance (i.e. "agree to disagree" and remain friends) among others, and bitter disagreement and unfriending with still others.
I'm distressed to say that a number of people haven't let go of their positions, even now that the election is over, and are continuing to bash those who don't agree with them. Yesterday a friend posted a chart to show that the states that went for Romney instead of Obama were populated by uneducated people, calling it proof positive that conservatives were stupid. I objected, pointing out that most states' votes were divided between O and R, and were not necessarily indicative of intelligence, and that this was an erroneous generalization. One of her FB friends (who was also one of mine) commented: "Denise, wake up, you live in the most whacked out, bizarre state in the country and you bitch about FACTS?? Smell the coffee, lady, and GROW THE HELL UP!"
Now that's an intelligent argument! What a fine representative of the liberal side she is.
I'm rethinking my friend list. It started with family and IRL friends. I built it up among those with a connection to adoption, not just to promote my book but because of our shared interest in family preservation and adoption reform. I didn't expect them to agree with me on everything, but I thought there would be some civility and courtesy. Apparently not.
I will not unfriend long-time friends and family members with whom I disagree. We love each other and those relationships aren't build on political or philosophical sameness. But I am going to look at the FB friendships that have become toxic and make some decisions along those lines.
I remain open to differing opinions. But I expect that my comments are welcome among those who share theirs, or they wouldn't put it out there in the public eye. Just as I welcome different views on my posts.
11 comments:
I completely understand.
You likely saw me struggling with same (and I am one of those moderate liberals that does not agree with your views but does agree with your right to have them and see nothing to be gained in debating them.
I have also rethought my friends but not because of politics per se. But the election showed some of their true values on racism, homophobia and women's rights that I sincerely don't want around me or my children. You might recall a blog post I made earlier in the year where the husband of a friend went on about the gays (lesbians really) and I sat there cringing but biting my tongue. My children were not present and I tolerated it. Not sure I can much longer.
I am a pro-choice white female that believes in women's reproductive rights. I have had family members on (and off) welfare. I have a queer daughter. I have black friends whom I love. I am first generation in this country born to a father that was conceived in a concentration camp. I work hard, pay my taxes, am raising decent productive children.
The racism, homophobia, jingoism, etc. I can hide their feed on Facebook, I can put them in restricted Facebook list but how do I hide their attitude in real life?
Havent figured that one out yet but have certainly rethought who I will socialize with and who I wont going forward.
I have the privilege of having a lot of misogynistic males that seem to think that I am too stupid to make informed decisions. We have agreed that religion and politics are not something we will ever agree on and that discussing it will not be a good thing... so we won't - ever! But unfriend them because their are idiots? no.....
Suz, it seems to me that we agree on most things. With the exception of the size of government and its intervention in citizens' lives. Perhaps this makes me a moderate conservative. Very true, differences on important issues are far easier to do with on FB (where we can hide or ignore) than in real life interactions.
It is a challenging position. Debating this with my hubby and family last night. Do we stand silent when faced with racism, homophobia or do we say something? If we dont state our objections (by defriending, limiting social interaction, letting our feelings be known, or other) arent we essentially condoning the behavior?
"All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing"
But what if your friend doesnt consider racism or homophobia to be evil?
(Yeah, thinking too much as usual!)
"All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing"
Agree 100%! And yes, we should stand up against evil opinions. Silence infers agreement.
The old "if you don't agree with me you are stupid" argument. Right up there with "all____s are _____" Drives me nuts.
Friendship requires respect.
Margie
Thanks, Margie. I am not a racist. All if my IRL friends knows that. But if I don't vote for Obama, I am accused of being one by those who don't know me. Goes to show that skin color matters more than it should after all. The accusation that those who vote for a white man have no other reason — such as better policies — than that he is white. There is an assumption that if you vote repub or libertarian, or anything other than demo, you are a racist, homophobic idiot.
You're right. True friendship does include respect, even if you disagree.
I totally understand your frustration, Denise. That one person you quoted certainly doesn't sound like a friend. I prefer the "agree to disagree" and then move on to areas of common ground. For me, the outcome of this year's election was an epic disappointment and I'm still recovering! The massive debt, the fiscal cliff, the scandals, and the dire economy have me very worried for the future of our country.
i TOTALLY identify. My main reason for being on FB is networking re adoption and my book. Butr I am also a very opinionated and political person, so, my views are now well known.
I have been unfriended by SEVERAL during the election. So be it.
I have never unfreinded anyone for a differenc eof opinion - but i have had to unfriend some for being abusive.
Mirah, thank you for your comment. The way I see it is true friends (although FB stretches the definition) don't dump each other over differences of opinion. Although I have been. Agree, verbal abuse warrants. I thought what J. said on your post was, and hence, unfriended her.
I agree with you Denise. Life is sweeter without mean spirited "friends". I avoid them like the plague.
Margie
Post a Comment